top of page

Book Warning: Staying Attune to Subtle Influences


Little Homesteader - A Winter Treasury

Last night, I was reviewing a book that upon first glance looked like it might be a great addition to our list of recommendations. It comes from a series, ‘Little Homesteader’ which has a book for each season. As I was going through the book for winter, ‘A Winter Treasury’, I had made it all the way to the end, but the last two-page spread (you can expand the picture below) made me feel a little uneasy…so I did a little digging.


While the majority of the book is filled with fun holiday crafts and recipes, facts about animals and plants, and ideas for embracing the colder weather, the last two pages brought up the celebration of the Winter Solstice. Sounds innocent enough, right? But growing up Christian, I was never really taught about the Winter Solstice outside of it being the day with the least sunlight. My lack of knowledge left me wondering about its significance. Turns out, the reason it was skipped in my upbringing was for a good reason.

Winter Solstice

As Christian parents, it is our responsibility to be vigilant and discerning about the content our children are exposed to. Some books, under the guise of innocence, subtly aim to influence our children towards ideas and beliefs that may be contrary to our faith. After I did some research, I learned more about the celebration of the winter solstice, a seemingly benign topic that, on closer examination, reveals connections to pagan practices such as Wicca.

The winter solstice, the longest night of the year, is a natural event that occurs annually. It marks the turning point when the days begin to grow longer, ultimately leading to the rebirth of light and life in the spring. In itself, the solstice is a fascinating and beautiful aspect of our world's natural rhythm. However, when presented to our children through literature as an event to celebrate, it may subtly introduce them to beliefs and practices that do not align with our Christian faith.

Books that celebrate the winter solstice may seem harmless at first glance, but upon closer inspection, they often incorporate elements from Wiccan and pagan traditions. Wicca is a modern pagan, witchcraft religion that has been on the rise, with its adherents celebrating the winter solstice as one of its MAJOR holidays. While we respect the diversity of beliefs in our society, it is crucial for us as Christians to be mindful of the potential influence these ideas may have on our children's faith and values.


The danger of these subtly influential books lies in the way they normalize and romanticize practices that are contrary to Christian beliefs. Through beautifully illustrated stories (or in the case of the Little Homemaker - Winter Treasury book, a craft idea to celebrate this day), children may be introduced to rituals, symbols, and beliefs that may lead them down a path of curiosity and exploration, ultimately diverting them from the Christian truth.

As parents and guardians, we must not only read the books our children are exposed to but also engage in conversations with them about the content. Encourage your children to ask questions and express their thoughts and feelings. In these dialogues, we can help them discern the subtle influences these books may have on their hearts and minds.


We must be vigilant in our role as protectors of our children's hearts and minds. While it is important to encourage a love of reading and exploration, it is equally vital to discern the subtle influences that some books may carry. Select literature that aligns with your Christian values. Seek out books that promote love, kindness, and the teachings of Jesus Christ. Choose stories that reinforce moral principles and inspire faith.


At Pure Pages Library, we are working hard to promote books that align with the teachings of the Bible. We hope to become your go-to resource for discovering high-quality books that align with your values, and connect with a community of parents who share your commitment to providing wholesome reading material for kids.


Have you had an experience like this? Do you think this is a reach or over-reaction? Maybe you have mixed feelings? We'd love to know what you think!


**SIDE NOTE** If the book had only mentioned the winter solstice as being the day with the least amount of sunlight and encouraged a scientific observation, I would have been totally fine with that. But when it was encouraging children to celebrate this day, I begin to feel uncomfortable. I realize my radar is on HIGH for things like this!

176 views6 comments

6 Comments


Guest
Nov 11, 2023

This is so well written.


I have a similar story. I was building a winter booklist for kids. I stumbled upon "The Shortest Day" by Susan Cooper. (She's one to steer away from). But it was about the winter solstice and the kids were dancing around a fire and de*** spirits were coming from the flames.


This was on many respected booklists. 😳😳😳


I hate the sneaking it in!

Like

Guest
Nov 11, 2023

Thank you for being so thorough in your review! I appreciate your explanation of Winter Solstice because I too grew up with a limited explanation of the day. This is a great blog for Christian families to read!

Like

It’s a slippery slope. What begins as something harmless and fun can subltley turn into something far more sinister.

Like

Guest
Nov 10, 2023

Good to know! If a Christian lifestyle is your family’s goal, knowing the underlining meaning of pagan traditions help parents/adults make educated decisions for their families.

Like

Lauren Thompson
Lauren Thompson
Nov 10, 2023

I appreciate the thorough review. I have limited knowledge about Winter Solstice and want to steer clear of anything related to Wicca or witches. God gives us instincts we need to follow, like yours leading to further investigation of something that could have seemed innocent. Our children are too important to risk misleading them. We enjoy nature and want that point us to worship of our Creator, not worshipping His creations. Thank you for your diligence!

Like
Nikki Yankee
Nikki Yankee
Dec 09, 2023
Replying to

Thank you for taking the time to read and engage with the review. I'm glad to hear that you found the information helpful. Your perspective on the importance of guiding children towards the worship of the Creator rather than His creations is a valuable one. Nature can indeed serve as a powerful reminder of the beauty and complexity of the world that God has created. I appreciate your diligence in navigating these matters with care, especially when it comes to the well-being and understanding of our children.

Like
bottom of page